fixed reporting errors in child templates

Sources/Errors.swift

@@ -99,7 +99,7 @@ open class SimpleErrorReporter: ErrorReporter {
 
     return TemplateSyntaxError(reason: (error as? TemplateSyntaxError)?.reason ?? "\(error)",
                                lexeme: (error as? TemplateSyntaxError)?.lexeme,
-                               template: context.template,
+                               template: (error as? TemplateSyntaxError)?.template ?? context.template,
                                parentError: (error as? TemplateSyntaxError)?.parentError
     )
   }

Sources/Inheritence.swift

@@ -1,25 +1,23 @@
 class BlockContext {
   class var contextKey: String { return "block_context" }
 
-  var blocks: [String: [BlockNode]]
+  // contains mapping of block names to their nodes and templates where they are defined
+  var blocks: [String: [(BlockNode, Template?)]]
 
-  init(blocks: [String: BlockNode]) {
+  init(blocks: [String: (BlockNode, Template?)]) {
-    self.blocks = [:]
+    self.blocks = blocks.mapValues({ [$0] })
-    blocks.forEach { (key, value) in
-      self.blocks[key] = [value]
-    }
   }
 
-  func push(_ block: BlockNode, forKey blockName: String) {
+  func pushBlock(_ block: BlockNode, named blockName: String, definedIn template: Template?) {
     if var blocks = blocks[blockName] {
-      blocks.append(block)
+      blocks.append((block, template))
       self.blocks[blockName] = blocks
     } else {
-      self.blocks[blockName] = [block]
+      self.blocks[blockName] = [(block, template)]
     }
   }
   
-  func pop(_ blockName: String) -> BlockNode? {
+  func popBlock(named blockName: String) -> (node: BlockNode, template: Template?)? {
     if var blocks = blocks[blockName] {
       let block = blocks.removeFirst()
       if blocks.isEmpty {
@@ -87,28 +85,33 @@ class ExtendsNode : NodeType {
       throw TemplateSyntaxError("'\(self.templateName)' could not be resolved as a string")
     }
 
-    let template = try context.environment.loadTemplate(name: templateName)
+    let baseTemplate = try context.environment.loadTemplate(name: templateName)
+    let template = context.environment.template
     
     let blockContext: BlockContext
-    if let context = context[BlockContext.contextKey] as? BlockContext {
+    if let _blockContext = context[BlockContext.contextKey] as? BlockContext {
-      blockContext = context
+      blockContext = _blockContext
-
+      for (name, block) in blocks {
-      for (key, value) in blocks {
+        blockContext.pushBlock(block, named: name, definedIn: template)
-        blockContext.push(value, forKey: key)
       }
     } else {
-      blockContext = BlockContext(blocks: blocks)
+      blockContext = BlockContext(blocks: blocks.mapValues({ ($0, template) }))
     }
 
     do {
-      return try context.environment.pushTemplate(template, token: token) {
+      // pushes base template and renders it's content
+      // block_context contains all blocks from child templates
+      return try context.environment.pushTemplate(baseTemplate, token: token) {
         try context.push(dictionary: [BlockContext.contextKey: blockContext]) {
-          return try template.render(context)
+          return try baseTemplate.render(context)
         }
       }
     } catch {
-      if let parentError = error as? TemplateSyntaxError {
+      // if error template is already set (see catch in BlockNode)
-        throw TemplateSyntaxError(reason: parentError.reason, parentError: parentError)
+      // and it happend in the same template as current template
+      // there is no need to wrap it in another error
+      if let error = error as? TemplateSyntaxError, error.template !== context.environment.template {
+        throw TemplateSyntaxError(reason: error.reason, parentError: error)
       } else {
         throw error
       }
@@ -142,15 +145,31 @@ class BlockNode : NodeType {
   }
 
   func render(_ context: Context) throws -> String {
-    if let blockContext = context[BlockContext.contextKey] as? BlockContext, let node = blockContext.pop(name) {
+    if let blockContext = context[BlockContext.contextKey] as? BlockContext, let child = blockContext.popBlock(named: name) {
+      // node is a block node from child template that extends this node (has the same name)
       let newContext: [String: Any]
         newContext = [
           BlockContext.contextKey: blockContext,
+          // render current node so that it's content can be used as part of node that extends it
           "block": ["super": try self.render(context)]
         ]
-      
+      // render extension node
+      do {
         return try context.push(dictionary: newContext) {
-        return try node.render(context)
+          return try child.node.render(context)
+        }
+      } catch {
+        // child node belongs to child template, which is currently not on top of stack
+        // so we need to use node's template to report errors, not current template
+        // unless it's already set
+        if var error = error as? TemplateSyntaxError {
+          error.template = error.template ?? child.template
+          error.lexeme = error.lexeme ?? child.node.token
+
+          throw error
+        } else {
+          throw error
+        }
       }
     }
 

Tests/StencilTests/EnvironmentSpec.swift

@@ -228,20 +228,10 @@ func testEnvironment() {
         var error = expectedSyntaxError(token: "include \"invalid-include.html\"", template: template, description: "Unknown filter 'unknown'")
         error.parentError = parentError
         
+
         try expect(environment.renderTemplate(string: template.templateString, context: ["target": "World"])).toThrow(error)
       }
       
-      $0.it("reports syntax error in extended template") {
-        let template = try environment.loadTemplate(name: "invalid-child-super.html")
-        let baseTemplate = try environment.loadTemplate(name: "invalid-base.html")
-        
-        let parentError = expectedSyntaxError(token: "target|unknown", template: baseTemplate, description: "Unknown filter 'unknown'")
-        var error = expectedSyntaxError(token: "extends \"invalid-base.html\"", template: template, description: "Unknown filter 'unknown'")
-        error.parentError = parentError
-
-        try expect(environment.render(template: template, context: ["target": "World"])).toThrow(error)
-      }
-      
       $0.it("reports runtime error in included template") {
         var environment = environment
         let filterExtension = Extension()
@@ -260,23 +250,58 @@ func testEnvironment() {
         try expect(environment.renderTemplate(string: template.templateString, context: ["target": "World"])).toThrow(error)
       }
 
-      $0.it("reports runtime error in extended template") {
+      $0.it("reports syntax error in base template") {
-        var environment = environment
+        let template = try environment.loadTemplate(name: "invalid-child-super.html")
-        let filterExtension = Extension()
+        let baseTemplate = try environment.loadTemplate(name: "invalid-base.html")
-        filterExtension.registerFilter("throw", filter: {  (_: Any?) in
-          throw TemplateSyntaxError("filter error")
-        })
-        environment.extensions += [filterExtension]
 
-        let template = try environment.loadTemplate(name: "invalid-runtime-child-super.html")
+        let parentError = expectedSyntaxError(token: "target|unknown", template: baseTemplate, description: "Unknown filter 'unknown'")
-        let baseTemplate = try environment.loadTemplate(name: "invalid-runtime-base.html")
+        var error = expectedSyntaxError(token: "extends \"invalid-base.html\"", template: template, description: "Unknown filter 'unknown'")
-        
-        let parentError = expectedSyntaxError(token: "target|throw", template: baseTemplate, description: "filter error")
-        var error = expectedSyntaxError(token: "extends \"invalid-runtime-base.html\"", template: template, description: "filter error")
         error.parentError = parentError
 
         try expect(environment.render(template: template, context: ["target": "World"])).toThrow(error)
       }
+
+      $0.it("reports runtime error in base template") {
+        var environment = environment
+        let filterExtension = Extension()
+        filterExtension.registerFilter("unknown", filter: {  (_: Any?) in
+          throw TemplateSyntaxError("filter error")
+        })
+        environment.extensions += [filterExtension]
+
+        let template = try environment.loadTemplate(name: "invalid-child-super.html")
+        let baseTemplate = try environment.loadTemplate(name: "invalid-base.html")
+
+        let parentError = expectedSyntaxError(token: "target|unknown", template: baseTemplate, description: "filter error")
+        var error = expectedSyntaxError(token: "extends \"invalid-base.html\"", template: template, description: "filter error")
+        error.parentError = parentError
+
+        try expect(environment.render(template: template, context: ["target": "World"])).toThrow(error)
+      }
+      
+      $0.it("reports syntax error in child template") {
+        let template = Template.init(templateString: "{% extends \"base.html\" %}\n" +
+          "{% block body %}Child {{ target|unknown }}{% endblock %}", environment: environment, name: nil)
+        let error = expectedSyntaxError(token: "target|unknown", template: template, description: "Unknown filter 'unknown'")
+        
+        try expect(environment.render(template: template, context: ["target": "World"])).toThrow(error)
+      }
+      
+      $0.it("reports runtime error in child template") {
+        var environment = environment
+        let filterExtension = Extension()
+        filterExtension.registerFilter("unknown", filter: {  (_: Any?) in
+          throw TemplateSyntaxError("filter error")
+        })
+        environment.extensions += [filterExtension]
+        
+        let template = Template.init(templateString: "{% extends \"base.html\" %}\n" +
+          "{% block body %}Child {{ target|unknown }}{% endblock %}", environment: environment, name: nil)
+        let error = expectedSyntaxError(token: "{{ target|unknown }}", template: template, description: "filter error")
+        
+        try expect(environment.render(template: template, context: ["target": "World"])).toThrow(error)
+      }
+      
     }
     
   }